Concerns persist over R466A compatibility


United states of america: New checks on R466A, Honeywell’s prolonged-awaited non-flammable decreased GWP alternative air conditioning refrigerant, are claimed to have proven equivalent performance to R410A but have yet again lifted substance compatibility problems.  

To start with declared by Honeywell in June 2018, R466A is a mix of R32 and R125 – the two parts of R410A – with the addition of 39.5% of trifluoroiodomethane, much better recognised as CF3I or R13I1. In spite of the preliminary industry enthusiasm, extra than 3 a long time on, R466A has continue to not been adopted by any OEM in a manufacturing product. And this is in spite of Honeywell insisting that R466A has undergone “extensive analysis” by OEMs and leading compressor producers. 

The hottest exams by the College of California, Davis, Western Cooling Performance Heart (WCEC), evaluated its overall performance in a Trane Basis rooftop device. The effects have been described as “very successful” displaying similar capability and COP across a extensive assortment of outdoor air problems. 

On the other hand, the UC Davis tests once more problem its material compatibility, stating that it represented a viable substitute to R410A “if the compatibility troubles with specified metals can be mitigated through the use of substitute elements and suitable additives”.

UC Davis refers to “documented concerns” all over the chemical balance of the R-13I1 part which, they say, “reacts with zinc causing the molecule to crack down”.

Honeywell has previously countered such statements, telling the Cooling Put up that the steadiness and shelf-lifetime can be resolved with normal actions practiced in the field.

Additive

The most current assessments had been carried out on a new 15-ton Trane Foundation product, brought in to switch an present 15-ton Trane R22 design on the roof of one particular of the UC Davis campus structures. The RTU was in the beginning billed with R466A and an unspecified oil additive, which the UC Davis scientists reported was “to stay away from compatibility issues” with R466A.

The additive applied in the exams was mentioned to have been designed by Trane Technologies especially to strengthen the compatibility of R13I1 with system supplies. The Trane Basis device was a production packaged R410A RTU, wherever the R410A experienced been recovered and replaced with R466A.

The procedure with R466A was monitored from July 13 to August 29, 2021. It was then replaced with R410A and monitored by means of to September 29. There was no charge optimisation executed for either refrigerant. In both scenarios, the procedure was charged with the nameplate amount of 14.6lbs, which was advised for R410A.

A former study, by WCEC, found that a refrigerant demand optimisation for R466A necessary minimal adjustments to the thermal enlargement valve and a 7% boost in refrigerant weight when compared to R410A to compensate for distinctions in refrigerant liquid densities. This task appeared at the worst-scenario situation for a fall-in replacement, where no charge optimisation was done and the charge was simply primarily based on company recommendations for R410A. 

The assessments

In the exams, R466A appeared to deliver marginally increased capacity than R410A as out of doors temperatures greater, but, in common, the potential distinctions among the two refrigerants had been in just the margin of error of the measurements. 

Ability attract assessments confirmed R466A to have a a little steeper profile with decrease electricity attract at decrease out of doors air temperatures and higher energy attract at increased out of doors air temperatures. Nonetheless, the UC Davis engineers recognised that this increase in electric power attract could be attributed to the lack of a charge optimisation with R466A. In terms of COP, the refrigerants showed very similar across all outside air temperature conditions.

The normal subcooling in the course of the measurement period of time was 9.0°F for R466A and 4.1°F for R410A

Related stories:

Trane to carry out area trials on R466A29 June 2021
United states: Honeywell and Trane are to conduct subject tests on Trane rooftop models with R466A – Honeywell’s prolonged-awaited non-flammable alternate refrigerant to R410A. Read more…

Honeywell associates with Sporlan on R466A refrigerant – 19 September 2019
United states of america: The Sporlan Division of controls and components producer Parker Hannifin has specified the thumbs up to R466A, Honeywell’s but to be introduced reduced GWP, non-flammable substitution for R410A. Read more…

Honeywell joins forces with Sanhua on R466A – 14 August 2019
United states of america: Honeywell has joined forces with Sanhua, the Chinese air conditioning and refrigeration controls and components manufacturer, to commercialise the use of R466A, Honeywell’s decreased GWP R410A alternative refrigerant. Read more…

Midea opts for Honeywell’s A1 aircon refrigerant R466A – 26 June 2019
United states of america/CHINA: Chinese company Midea is looking to use Solstice N41 (R466A), Honeywell’s new non-flammable, decreased GWP refrigerant, in all its VRF and chiller devices. Read more…

Promising outcomes for R466A in VRF air con checks – 10 January 2019
United states of america: Toshiba Carrier is explained to have explained R466A, Honeywell’s new non-flammable R410A substitution, as “promising” after initial performance tests in a VRF air conditioning program. Read more…

R466A has close efficiency to R410A – 14 October 2018
GERMANY: Solstice N41, Honeywell’s new non-flammable reduce GWP refrigerant, is mentioned to have general performance characteristics near to R410A. Read more…

Honeywell’s N41 – a blast from the previous – 24 August 2018
CF3I is, seemingly, the mysterious quantity in Solstice N41, Honeywell’s new R410A alternative refrigerant. But the information exhibit that much from getting new to the refrigerants company, it has been thought of as a component in replacements for CFCs, HCFCs as properly as HFCs in exams relationship back again at the very least 30 many years. Could the previously adoption of CF3I have saved the marketplace a range of system modifications alongside the way? Read more…

Magic formula of Honeywell’s new refrigerant – 27 June 2018
United states of america: Honeywell’s growth of a non-flammable minimal GWP alternative to R410A has produced enormous desire, but what is in it? The Cooling Put up may possibly have the reply. Read more…

Honeywell announces R410A breakthrough – 26 June 2018
United states: Honeywell has announced the enhancement of a new decrease GWP non-flammable different to R410A in stationary air conditioning devices. Read more…



Supply backlink

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

eight − two =